The 9 Best Pie Dishes to Make Pies

Published on: November 06, 2022

Baking a pie that is flaky and, preferably, golden, is a challenge for both beginner bakers and those with more expertise. Nevertheless, anyone who puts in a little bit of effort and has the right equipment, beginning with a sturdy pie dish, has the potential to achieve remarkable results.

It may be difficult to choose the best pie dishes from the vast number of options offered by manufacturers. After much research and testing, we settled on the 9 Best Pie Dishes to Make Pies for Baking Cakes as our top picks to help you make the right decision.

Our Top Picks

1st

Pyrex Pie Dish
Product Rating
Bakewarely Score 98%

2nd

Product Rating
Bakewarely Score 97%

3rd

Product Rating
Bakewarely Score 96%

Top 9 Pie Dish to Choose

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 98%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.9/5
89% of 11,837 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
1 Available Color

Things We Liked

  • High-quality glass pie dishes
  • Non-porous and non-stick
  • Sturdy tempered glass dishes

The most significant advantage of a glass baking dish is the ability to monitor the baking process. For example, if you are baking a pie, you can see the progress of your pie. Even though the top crust is an attractive golden brown, the bottom crust may require a few more minutes to thoroughly cook, especially if the filling is liquid. To determine whether your pie crust is thoroughly cooked, use a glass plate like the Pyrex Easy Grab pie glass dish.

Pyrex is offering a two-piece pie baking dish set that is constructed from high-quality glass that is non-porous, flavor- and odor-resistant, and stain-resistant. The rims of these Pyrex glass pie plates have a wave pattern, which makes them easier to handle and more convenient for moving baking dishes from the oven to the table. Additionally, it provides the food with a hint of style, adorns the table with a flourish, and makes the glass pie dishes perfect for serving.

Because they are made of glass, these glass pie dishes make it simple to remove baked foods from the dish while also providing a non-stick surface. These plates are safe to use in the oven, the microwave, the dishwasher, and the freezer thanks to the sturdy tempered glass that they are made of.

If you enjoy baking pies in glass bakeware, this Pyrex set of glass pie dishes is excellent for you.

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 97%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.9/5
86% of 2,406 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
1 Available Color

Things We Liked

  • Heavy-gauged aluminized steel
  • Gives a beautiful brown crust to the pie
  • Ideal for everyday use

One of the most crucial elements in baking pies successfully is a pie plate that evenly distributes heat to the pie and gives it a gorgeous brown crust. USA Pan is here with a pie pan that satisfies all criteria for a top-notch pie pan.

The best pie dish produced in the USA Pan is made of heavy-gauge aluminized steel and has a strong structure. It also includes a silicone coating that is devoid of PFOA and BPA. Food does not adhere to the pie pan because the silicone coating creates a nonstick surface, and baked pies release effortlessly. Hand washing with warm water, soap, and a soft sponge has been shown to help keep the nonstick coating.

The generous edges on this best pie dish are great for a secure and safe hold, whether you are placing the pie pan in the oven or pulling it out of the oven. We were impressed by the pie dish made by USA Pan because it included a one-of-a-kind textured surface that ensures even heat distribution, increases air circulation, reinforces the dish so that it does not deform, and offers a gorgeous golden-brown crust for the pie.

USA Pan’s pie dish is designed to last for a long time, to be reliable, and to perform exceptionally well, making it the best option for achieving everyday baking success. This best pie pan is an excellent investment for you if you enjoy making a variety of pies at home.

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 96%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.8/5
85% of 2,922 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
1 Available Color

Things We Liked

  • High-quality glass pie dish
  • Easy cleanup
  • Bakes pies evenly

Anchor Hocking is known for high-quality glass bakeware, food storage, beverageware, serveware, and pantry storage products that are ideal for the preparation, presentation, and preservation of food that every family will enjoy. A glass pie dish is now available from Anchor Hocking, making baking pies quick and efficient.

This best glass pie dish comes in a perfect regular size and has a good enough deepness that can contain as many fillings as you want. It features handles that are bigger and have a slight ridge, which makes them easier to grip.

Instead of using a dish with a chemical coating, we liked that it is made of thick, robust glass and you can create a nonstick surface by lightly coating it with oil or cooking spray. When cooking, if something starts to get a little burned, simply scrub it with hot water and soak it for 20 to 30 minutes. makes it quite simple to clean! This best glass pie dish came out of the dishwasher pristine, with no breaks, shattering, or scratches.

Anchor Hocking glass pie dishes are healthier than metal and plastic because they do not warp, discolor, retain odors, or leach harmful chemicals into meals. The dish’s high-quality glass bakes pies evenly, gives them a lovely brown crust, and keeps them warm. It’s self-contained, so all you have to do is serve it up when the timer goes off and dig in!

You can use this glass pie dish in gas or electric ovens up to 425 degrees F without scorching the pies, and it’s also ideal for storing them in the fridge or freezer.

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 95%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.8/5
73% of 248 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
1 Available Color

Things We Liked

  • High-quality steel
  • Distributes heat uniformly
  • Easy release of the baked pie

G&S Metal Products Company is now offering the best pie dish that will not only make the process of baking more joyful and interesting for you but will also allow you to cook your favorite pie to perfection.

The steel used in the construction of this dish is of the highest quality and is non-toxic. To provide nonstick performance, this pie dish is coated with a nonstick finish. Cleaning is a breeze. This coating ensures high-quality performance, which makes this an ideal pie pan for enduring the wear and tear that comes with regular use.

Because this best pie dish has a non-stick coating, there was no need for us to spray any oil on it before using it to bake our pie. The baked pie did not adhere to the dish at all, and it was quite easy to remove the pie from this best pie dish even though no oil or butter had been used.

Because the dish is resistant to heat, heat is spread evenly over the whole surface. This makes sure that the pie bakes evenly. Additionally, it gives the pie a gorgeous golden-brown crust.

This best pie dish made by G&S Metal Products Company would be a wonderful addition to the kitchen of anyone who has a passion for making their own pies at home and is in need of a high-quality pie baking dish.

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 93%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.5/5
72% of 140 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
1 Available Color

Things We Liked

  • High-quality aluminum foil
  • Bakes evenly
  • Doesn’t contain any chemicals

When you are baking for a special occasion, such as a potluck, where you surely don’t want to give away your favorite pie dish along with your pie, foil dishes are a wonderful option. You can also use them when you are baking for your house. Waytiffer is giving you 10 individual pie dishes made of foil to meet your needs.

These reusable aluminum foil pie plates are well-made. Because these best pie dishes don’t have any chemicals in them, there is no risk of chemicals leaching into the foods that are being baked, and this ensures that the baking will be healthy. When you don’t feel like cleaning, you can also throw away the aluminum foil dishes. As Waytiffer foil dishes come in a size that is just right, they are an excellent choice for using with any standard pie recipe.

During testing, these foil pie plates functioned well under high heat and baked pies as evenly and rapidly as other materials. They created pies with flaky, golden brown crusts that were flawless.

Waytiffer’s individual pot pie dishes can also be used to freeze unbaked pie crust stacks, which is useful if you do a lot of baking and want to ensure that you have unbaked pie crusts on hand when you need them.

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 94%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.7/5
88% of 2,062 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
1 Available Color

Things We Liked

  • Ceramic pie dish
  • Distributes heat uniformly
  • Deep pie dish

With a deep-dish pie, you can pack more fruit filling and meat into your shepherd’s pie while still having room for a good helping of mashed potatoes on top. This wonderful Farberware ceramic pie dish has a deep capacity that is ideal for your favorite apple pie or savory pies such as chicken pot pie, shepherd’s pie, and many more.

This best pie dish, which is made of ceramic, distributes heat uniformly, allowing the crust to brown evenly all around. It works well in the oven and can bake pies as well as savory dishes like meatloaf or scalloped potatoes. For storing the pies, this dish can go in the freezer, and it can also go in the microwave for reheating the leftovers. Even though hand washing is recommended, the ceramic finish is made to make it easy for food particles to come off, which makes cleanup quick and easy. We noticed a few light lines on the surface of the pottery after cutting pie slices, but all of the marks were cleaned out with soapy water.

In order to determine how much filling could be contained in this best pie dish, we filled the pie dish with a lot of fruit for an apple pie, to see how much filling would fit within. We were impressed that the crust cooked evenly on the bottom without getting soggy, and that the apples cooked perfectly and evenly throughout the pie without turning into applesauce.

We had a great time baking with this Farberware pie plate, which is known for its high quality and stylish look.

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 95%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.7/5
85% of 211 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
1 Available Color

Things We Liked

  • High-quality borosilicate glass
  • Can monitor baking easily
  • Distributes heat evenly

Lifesence is offering a set of pie dishes that come in two different sizes which can be used to bake full-size pies or smaller pies, depending on your preferences.

These borosilicate glass pie dishes are of the highest quality, contain no lead, and are completely safe to use. Since borosilicate glass does not take on odors or stains, it is an excellent option for the storage of acidic foods. They come with a surface that is non-stick, which prevents items from adhering and makes it simple to remove them after baking. With a classic fishbone pattern in the non-stick interior, these glass pie dishes add a special touch of elegance and vitality to the pie.

Pie dishes made of borosilicate glass of high quality can withstand sudden shifts in temperature, making them far more durable and superior to other types of glass. Because they distribute heat evenly across the dish, these glass pie dishes are ideal for baking pies to a perfect golden brown all the way through. To make them easier to hold, as well as to provide a secure and smooth transfer of the dishes, the corners of the handles have been rounded off. As they come with a transparent appearance, this glass pie dishes make it easier to monitor baking and keep an eye on the bottom crust of the pie.

Lifesence glass pie dishes are a terrific addition to any kitchen because they can be used not only as a pie dish but also as plates to eat on.

Product Rating

Bakewarely Score 92%

Bakewarely has published the review by testing this for hours in kitchen and based on honest customer review from Amazon.

Things We Noticed

4.5/5
89% of 1,508 Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars
4 Available Colors

Things We Liked

  • High-quality ceramic dishes
  • Doesn’t absorb odors or flavors

Making pies that are both flaky and ideally golden can be a challenging task for inexperienced cooks as well as those with more baking experience. Nevertheless, stunning outcomes are within grasp for anyone who puts in a little bit of effort and has the appropriate equipment, beginning with a strong pie dish. Le Tauci is providing a set of two ceramic pie dishes to make your desired pies perfectly.

These high-quality ceramic pie dishes are not only ideal for making homemade fruit pies, pot pies, crisps, and quiches, but they are also compatible with the standard pie crust that can be purchased at the supermarket. The fluted rim makes it simple to create a stunning crust with the pie dough, regardless of whether you are creating a Lorraine, quiche, apple pie, or any other type of pie, and also improves the grip.

Because it properly distributes heat during baking and is oven-safe up to 482 degrees F, the ceramic pie dishes transform pie baking from ordinary to art. Long-lasting for everyday usage. Due to the durable coating, these best ceramic pie dishes do not absorb odors or flavors from food.

Le Tauci’s ceramic pie dishes are a great addition to every baker’s kitchen who loves to make their own pies with a professional baking experience.

See More